top of page

Open Journal Short Stories 2026

Many thanks to all the short story writers who continue to submit to Superlative.

Here are the fantastic short stories we selected for publication in our open journal in 2026.

If you would like us to consider your short story for publication, please submit here.

Enjoy!

Iris

​​​

​And I’d give up forever to touch you

Cause I know that you feel me somehow.

 

It’s 2 AM on a humid summer night, and I am careening down an oceanside road in my parents’ beige Subaru Outback with my month-old driver’s license tucked loosely under my sweaty thigh. The sunroof is open, all the windows are down, and my hair whips my face with intoxicating, glorious stings of pain. I press the gas pedal further and further down, picturing headlines in the local newspaper, “Reckless Teen Speeds Through Residential Streets and Straight Off Ocean Cliff.” I smile with fearless cockiness. I know that I am young and invincible. I am destined to live long enough to make it to tomorrow night.

​

I check my rearview mirror to make sure she’s still behind me. Olivia, my best friend, in her parents’ dark blue Subaru Forester. Our sister “lesbian cars” who, despite their drivers’ complete sobriety, playfully swerve across lanes and race one another past expensive Catholic schools and private beaches. We throw up middle fingers to each other as we pull dangerous stunts and flirt with the prospect of a roadside death. It’s a small, sleepy town, and we adore the feeling that, at this hour, the 8-mile-wide island we’ve been trapped on is completely ours.

 

I turn up the speakers, blasting our song on full, throbbing volume. It’s “Iris” by the GooGoo Dolls: a quasi-rock song so painfully overplayed that its lyrics have turned into a bit of a joke, but we will defend its honor until we are buried to a bagpipe cover of the tune. Olivia and I are old enough to discover and appreciate hit music from the times before we were born, and young enough to still think it’s groundbreaking and cool. For some reason, we decide to make John Rzeznik’s 1998 melancholic hit our modern-day anthem. There’s something in the recklessness of the guitar, recorded by Rzeznik with two broken strings and a slew of discordant harmonies, that drives us into an instinctual head-slamming rock-out session every time we hear it.

 

On this night of infinite youth, the bass sends echoes through my seat that rattle something deep in my crotch. My voice screlts out, unbothered by the flurry of sour notes I hit. If I turn down the volume even just a little bit, I can hear Olivia scream-singing the same lyrics from her own car, our respective audio systems perfectly aligned to the rhythm of the song.

​

We finally reach the stoplight in front of the clam shack in the center of town. She pulls up next to me, and we gaze at each other through our open windows, smiles brimming through the darkness. When the light turns green, we turn in opposite directions, she to the left and I to the right, and head back to our respective family homes. I listen to the final minute of the song in deafening silence, tears brimming, my driving speed back to the respectable, legal limit.

 

You’re the closest to Heaven that I’ll ever be

And I don’t wanna go home right now.

 

Every night of every summer throughout high school, Olivia and I would replay this same scene. After our respective double shifts spent waiting tables at classy restaurants for posh millionaire tourists, we would meet each other at the top of our favorite lifeguard stand at our favorite beach in town. There, we would recount every little detail of our monotonous days and gaze up at the stars, pondering what to do with our savings once we were old enough to escape this dreary town and to leave our dysfunctional families and soul-sucking service jobs behind. It’s beautiful how mediocrity reads like torture when you’re that age.

 

And all I can taste is this moment

And all I can breathe is your life.

​

We dreamed up elaborate schemes of cross-country road trips to California until we outgrew our fantasies of American grandeur. We dreamed of hiking through Mexico and into Central American rainforests until we learned of drug cartels and sex traffickers. We dreamed of hopping through fields in remote German villages until we learned that they had all become industrialized tourist traps.

 

On the last night we spent together before leaving for our first year of college, Olivia and I determined that we would buy a sailboat and find a new tropical island to live out our days.

 

“Iris” sounded especially weepy that night as we lingered extra long at the stoplight. As we waved goodbye through rearview mirrors, I couldn’t shake the feeling that the next time we’d see each other, we would no longer be the invincible teenagers we had always believed we were.

 

And sooner or later, it’s over

I just don’t wanna miss you tonight.

​

When I returned home a year later, I limped towards our lifeguard stand in a cloud of shame and humiliation. A year into college, and I was a new person. Only, I hadn’t quite experienced the liberation and soul-searching I had dreamed of. Instead, I had found myself trapped once again, enduring over a year of repeated sexual harassment and assault at the hands of my female roommate. Unaware of the true seriousness of what had happened to me, confused and undermined by the betrayal of my fellow sex, I spent much of that summer with crippling depression. For weeks, I was unable to leave bed and felt nauseous at the prospect of spending time around my female friends.

 

And I don’t want the world to see me

Cause I don’t think that they’d understand.

 

After almost a month dodging Olivia’s eager text messages, she finally coaxes me to the beach: “If you don’t come see me tonight, I’m going to assume you’ve outgrown this friendship.” When I climb up the lifeguard tower to greet her, I feel a pang of despair in my heart. She has become a completely different person, too. Her long hair is now cut to a boyish pixie. She has a nose ring and several new ear piercings. She looks so badass, so much like the rock stars from the 80s we worshipped in middle school. So confident. So worldly. So sexy.

 

And she is furious with me.

​

When everything’s made to be broken

I just want you to know who I am.

 

I don’t know what excuse to give because I have no clue what the fuck is wrong with me. I stammer, and I choke up with tears.

 

Her cold demeanor instantly thaws, and she tries to wrap her arms around me. But I am nauseous and convulsing with labored breaths, and I push her away with a yelp.

 

I just want you to know who I am.

 

She’s shocked and visibly disturbed. And I can’t look at her as she watches me, hurt and perplexed.

 

It’s a long time until I let my voice crack with the sound of the waves breaking on the shore, “I’m sorry. I don’t know—”

 

She tells me, “It’s ok. You don’t have to.”

​

I just want you to know who I am.

 

She looks at me with her chestnut-brown eyes, and I realize that she is everything I have ever wanted and now can never have.

 

Because there is a part of me that is now broken and unfixable. The same part of her blossoms and grows on without me. And we realize that our past, present, and future are no longer the same. Everything is rewritten and reshaped. Even as we try to fit together, our puzzle pieces have warped to fit better elsewhere.

 

I just want you to know who I am.

 

It’s been three years since that night, and though Olivia and I try to see each other whenever we are in town, it has never been the same. When I hear “Iris” casually start playing on the radio, I have to turn it down. I have never been able to listen to John Rzeznik’s whiny vocals without wishing I were listening to Olivia’s angrier, pitchier rendition instead. Wishing that I were still a teenager fighting for freedom when I had no chains. That Olivia and I still believed that we owned our little island. That we were still playing with particles of sand and trying to understand our places in the universe.

 

That we were still singing that melancholic love song to each other before we realized why.

​

​

​​By Nastia Goddard

Nastia Goddard (née Anastasia Goddard) is an undergraduate student at Northwestern University studying Theatre and Creative Writing. She delights in telling stories both onstage and on the page that explore femininity, the turmoil of a human body's form, and the eternal struggle of self-discovery. She adores the absurd, the complicated, and the nonsensical, and she pushes her audiences to dive deep into their pasts, their fears, and their desires.

​

IG: @nastia_goddard

Website: nastiagoddard.com

The Fish at the End of the Car Crash

​​​​

​“I was on the verge of Becoming—” he began to say, before stopping himself.​

​​

Kate leaned in, touching a hand to his knee. “Becoming what?”

​

His eyes dragged down the length of her face, meandering along the hollow contours, and the curve of her nose, until they came to rest on her mouth. His gaze loitered there, taking in the subtle gradients of pink, and the tiny cracks in her plush lips that seemed to hint at a body accustomed to deprivation but not entirely made for it.

​

“Alex… becoming what?” she repeated.

​

Kate’s mouth continued to move. Open, closed, and then open again. The great reveal being a rosy tunnel of flushed accordion interior, glistening tongue, pearlescent teeth glinting against low-light, and an incisor with a barely noticeable chip in it. The tiny imperfection, etched in the enamel, flashed with her every attempt to comfort him.

​

I’ll show you mine, if you show me yours. It was enough to make Alex lean closer; he imagined reaching a hand out and grabbing Kate by the face, just so he could peer down into her. In return, she would open her mouth wider, and unhinge her jaw like a snake, consuming him with all but two words. Enter Me.

​

The inside of Kate was all intricately woven sinew, and porous marrow, and nerve endings that forgot to end, and a type of need that did not know how to stop needing. Her voice was soft though — the way he remembered his Nanny’s being; she was always trying to coax things out of him too. Things he wasn’t sure were even there to give.

​

Alex looked towards the window, a held breath escaping him. “I don’t know,” he replied, shaking his head. “Just, Becoming. Something. Other than myself.”

​

“So, growing.” The words drifted from Kate, matter-of-fact, like a dart burying itself deep in the wood beside a bullseye.

​

“No.” Alex’s back was still turned to her. His eyes locked on a plume of dark indigo clouds drifting across the sky like a half-healed bruise suspended in a molten twilight.

​

Kate blinked at him, owl-like. “So, if not growing then… what?”

​

Alex stole a glance over his shoulder at her, fighting the urge to roll his eyes. Kate just flashed him a toothy little grin, which was momentarily enough to redirect his annoyance into a subdued huff. He ran a hand over his dark blonde hair and let his gaze work over her delicate, half-starved, features until he eventually settled on her lips again.

​

Alex tilted his head, and took a step closer, eating the distance between them. He wanted her, he supposed, in the same way that a shark wants to know what flavor of beast a human on a surfboard is. With a lazy sort of gnawing curiosity; the kind that satiates itself, usually, with just one destructive taste.

​

“Why does it matter so much, hm?” He asked, crowding her. “Just curious? Trying to be nice? Bond. Imagining you’ll catch a glimpse of whatever you’ve decided I am.”

​

“Which is, apparently, a defensive asshole.”

​

Alex ignored the barb. “Kate,” he said, “you and I have a similar talent for surviving, but don’t imagine that makes us the same.” His voice lowered, as he leaned down to meet her, practically nose-to-nose, “We’re not kindred spirits, and I am not here to fill whatever void is inside of you. I’m—”

​

“I don’t care about how damaged you are,” Kate cut him off.

​

Alex took a step back, blinking at her in mute outrage. His lips parted to speak, but the only sound that escaped was a pathetic little, “…okay?” not dissimilar to a rusty door hinge creaking. He plunked down to the couch.

​

Kate fixed him with a look — some terrible cross between exasperation and loving condescension. “Have I ever told you about the reoccurring fantasy I have?” she asked, casual as ever. “The one where I’m driving down a highway alone — in the pitch black of night, and I press my foot to the gas? Going Seventy. Eighty. Ninety. A hundred miles per hour.”

​

“Kate—“

​

“Then I blink, and suddenly, the windows are all open. They’re open, Alex, but I don’t know why or how they came to be that way.”

​

Kate’s eyebrows drew closer as her voice trailed. She hugged her arms to her chest, fiddling with a loose thread at the sleeve of her sweater, as if the room had suddenly gone cold. “I’ve always hated when the wind whips my hair, ya know?” She said, exhaling a shaky breath. “The way it lashes my face and hurls fistfuls of flyaways into my eyes and mouth, refusing to behave even when I try to tuck the chaos away.”

​

Alex was spread out on the couch now, eyes half lidded and staring straight ahead. His legs were crossed at the ankle and his hands were shoved deep into the pockets of his hoodie.

​

“Anyway, like I was saying,” she continued, paying him no mind. “the windows are open — and I go to tuck my hair behind my ears, but I stop myself for some reason. And, instead, I let just let go. Of the wheel. The car spins out of control, and hurtles past oncoming traffic, straight into the trees, where a branch smashes through the windshield. And I just sit there… all impaled, and stuff… blinking in that startled, dazed way half-dead things tend to. Gaping at the blood leaking from my body, like I’m some sort of sentient punctured ziplock bag.”

​

Kate gave a half shrug. “Then a little fish leaps out from the wound, gasping for air. ‘This is your fault,’ it says. ‘Yes,’ I always say back, ‘Sorry ‘bout that.’  And we stare at each other, until one of us finally just dies…Usually the fish does first—“

​

“Does what?…”

​

“Dies.”

​

“Right…” Alex murmured.

​

“Other times, I die first,” Kate pressed on. “Either way, we’re both gasping for air, and by the end, neither of us has any left.”

​

Her eyes fixed on him then, dark grey and murky, like a well without a bottom. “What do you suppose it means?” She asked.

​

Alex scrubbed a hand over his jaw. “Kate — fuck — I don’t know. I’m not a dream dictionary.”

​

“It’s not a dream.”

​

“Well, it sounds like a dream.”

​

“But it means something,” she insisted, crossing the room and sitting beside him. “What. Does. It. Mean.”

​

Alex grimaced as Kate’s grip tightened on his thigh, bunching the fabric of his pants. “I don’t know,” He replied, peeling her hand away with enough pressure to blanche the surrounding skin. “Why are we arguing semantics anyway? Not every weird thought that pops into your head has some hidden cosmic meaning. God, you’re so fucking exhausting sometimes—”

​

Kate’s hand unclenched, fingers finally unfurling with a quiet resignation.

​

“I always knew you were the fish,” she whispered to herself, eyes somewhere far away.

 

​

​By Shayna Cristy-Mendez

Shayna Cristy-Mendez is a New York native, poet, film lover, and Riot Grrrl enthusiast. Her poetry has been featured in Beyond Words Literary Magazine, Luna Literary Journal, Tempered Runes Press, and Hawai'i Pacific Review. Shayna’s work delves into themes of isolation, trauma, and regeneration, often drawing from her own experiences. Never one to shy away from the darker aspects of life, her writing offers readers an unfiltered and unapologetic glimpse into the deeply personal.

​

Instagram: @viciouschipotle

Demolition 16

​​​

“We met in Barcelona,” she told a fellow actor backstage.

​

“In the Gaudí house, amid the tourist rush, I closed my eyes, made a wish, and there Roxanne appeared,” I added, sincerely.

​

Alternate versions of our origin story included drinking mini bottles of Jägermeister side-by-side at the Berlin Zoo while commenting in unison on how filthy the pandas looked. Locking eyes at the Carville leper colony in Louisiana while reading The Star, a weekly newsletter for the afflicted. Then there was me slipping on black ice in Montreal and waking to a stranger’s face asking if I was okay and me whispering, comment pourrais-je ne pas l'être ? Je viens de rencontrer l'amour de ma vie.

​

We carried on like this for months playing pranks on the unsuspecting, bending backstories into performance art.

​

Once, Roxanne slid her dead grandmother’s wedding ring into my coat pocket before we went out for drinks.

​

“Improv,” she said as we left her apartment.

​

Later, when I fake-proposed at the BRE Bar and she screamed YES! YES! YES!, the

whole place erupted, and we drank free Negronis all night.

​

Back then, I wrote stories for a living and Roxanne lived them aloud on stage. I reported crime for a newspaper while she performed songs on Broadway. Our desire to tell a better story is what brought us together.  

​

***

 

As a newly divorced 36-year-old man, I didn’t know how to date anymore. My most frequent communication with the opposite sex had become the daily guilting of my Blue Heeler, Maven, who always found herself licking bagel crumbs from the counter every morning.

 

As a reporter, I documented the dead but connecting with the living proved harder, perhaps because of my profession. Speaking with grieving families, contending with disgruntled NYPD liaisons at One Police Plaza, and writing stories for a public who largely hated you was not great for the human spirit. It paid rent, but it didn’t feed other parts that needed nourishing. But at my age and with my skill set – or lack thereof – there was no room to pivot which made the loneliness grow.

​

It was a photographer at a Bronx double-homicide who told me I looked blue one morning. That was the word he used: blue. He suggested one of the apps while we waited outside the 44th Precinct for the perp walk which was marred by the typical delays. Though the photographer was late into his fifties and south of handsome, with a crooked nose and fully retreated hairline, he found an implausible hot streak through online dating, leading to his engagement to a Ukrainian babysitter.

​

“If I could do it, you could do it,” he said. “Unless you’re crazy or something.”

​

Out of boredom or despair, I downloaded the app while waiting for the killer to be perp walked. I started the search by crawling through faces, names, and bios. There were countless women clutching drinks in foreign countries. Some held up trophy fish. Too many quoted the movie Tommy Boy. All seemed concerned with height.

​

When Roxanne first appeared on my screen, I almost kept swiping. Aviator sunglasses covered her hazel eyes. A baseball cap buried her cherry-smoked hair. Aside from her cheekbones, she was hard to see. I looked down and checked the basics:

​

Occupation: singer

Height: 5’7

Favorite quote: Everything will kill you. Make it something fun

​

I accidentally swiped while fumbling to put my phone down as the perp screamed, “Y’all got the wrong guy! I ain’t do shit!” while he was hauled past us in a Tyvek suit. I scribbled the quotes in my notepad, copied details and color, and called my Desk.

​

A few days later, my phone dinged.

​

I was buried in follow-up coverage of the killer’s ongoing case. The PCP-fueled rampage in Sheepshead Bay claimed four victims who were all slashed in broad daylight. Piecing together witness accounts with his mostly Russian neighbors, failing to get an interview at Riker’s, where he was being held, and gunning through court documents all day left me in the gavel-to-gavel coverage zone.

​

Buckets of popcorn and Rex Goliath filled out my nights.  Walking Maven in the mornings with my coffee began my days. Work completed the rest.

​

I didn’t open her message until Saturday.

​

“What’s your real name BTW?” she asked.

​

“What do you mean?” I typed.

​

“Chase Storm? What are you? A weatherman?”

​

I snapped a picture of my press pass and sent it.

​

“PROOF ENOUGH?”

​

From there, the puns, anecdotes, and well-time one-liners flowed. We exchanged numbers and went off the app. We mocked the grapefruit-skinned presidential candidate, shared travel stories, discussed our shared preoccupation with jazz, and named a film we could watch on repeat ad infinitum (The Hustler, for me, West Side Story, for her).

​

I didn’t tell her “Chase Storm” was a pen name born from a recent comeback after my second rehab stint.

​

After a week of this type of banter, she suggested we grab coffee in Washington Square Park.

​

***

 

Roxanne told me she landed her first screen credit as a baby in a hospital. The role in the show Miami Vice from 1985 still offered royalty checks that averaged about eight cents every month through syndication. This was the verbal resume and past lovers phase of our banter.

​

Her last boyfriend, she said, was an apocalypse prepper who spent $15,000 on “equipment” for the end of the world. Before that, she dated a journalist with facial hair too “clean-cut” and a jawline so effortlessly round that it made her ill to look at.

​

“Pierogi-face syndrome,” I offered.

​

She squinted.

​

“My mom’s term for my uncles in Connecticut and their round Polish faces,” I clarified.

​

She chuckled.

​

“Something like that.”

​

She told me about her last fling with a Jersey City guy who wouldn’t commit.

​

“A jabroni,” I offered.

​

She cackled at that then turned somber.

​

“Dating in New York is a nightmare,” she said, sipping her iced almond milk latte. “What about you?”

​

I told her – in my workwise verbal resume – that I started out as a teenage columnist at a Queens weekly, breaking stories about garbage pickup and excessive dog waste in the streets. I never saw even eight cents for anything I wrote back then.

​

I told her about the divorce and how undramatic it was. How there was no plate-smashing or drawn-out court scenes. No Netflix docuseries potential.

​

Over a butter chicken special in the East Village, after another argument about the same thing we always argued about, she put down her fork.

​

 “What do we do now?”

​

“Divorce,” I said. “These things don’t change.”

​

Four months later, it was legally over. I gave enough cash for a first-month and deposit, helped move her into a Park Slope one-bedroom, and took the dog. The apartment was one pets could not inhabit.

​

“Well, good for you,” Roxanne said. “Sounds like a dead-end, and you cut your losses.”

​

“It was,” I said, flicking a caterpillar off my motorcycle boot.

​

“You ride?” she asked, looking at the leather footwear.

​

I told her about the Harley Sportster I inherited from my old man. I detailed the rebuilt engine, the sidecar, and how I took solo trips to Montauk. After Labor Day, when the crowds cleared, and Ditch Plains was empty, and the Fishermen bars quieted down, I walked around aimlessly to find a sense of peace.

​

She lit up. Her grandfather, she said, had been a Hollywood character actor with a passion for motorcycles. On weekends he wasn’t working, he’d tear through LA tracks with Dennis Hopper.

​

“That’s where I got my stage name,” she said of her grandfather. “Kyle Quinn.”

​

Before Broadway, there were singing waitress gigs and off-off Broadway plays. When one of the leads in Funny Girl, a musical about Broadway star Fanny Brice, got cancer, and Roxanne stepped in, that was her major break.

​

Her childhood, she said, was mostly spent in the Hollywood Hills. She called herself a “Valley Girl,” several times. Her father – a doctor – left for town in Park City and a younger woman when she was a toddler. Her mother, who worked in production, briefly dated Phil Spector but remained single ever since.

​

“He was shorter than he looked in all the documentaries. He loved wearing wigs and shooting guns,” she said unsurprisingly.

​

Her mother told her: that woman he killed could have been me then begged her to find a nice Jewish doctor in Manhattan.

​

“Dating in New York is a nightmare,” she repeated, then frowned.

​

The June heat didn’t let up. As we sat on the green bench, I watched sweat trail down her pastel neck. Humidity clung to us like a layer. My shirt was damp, and I had to check several times to make sure I didn’t reek of onion sweat or bad weather.

​

We talked until dusk while joggers, dealers, chess players, NYU students, and old Beats drifted past. The air was thick with weed, body heat, and summer voltage. Somehow it felt romantic as time evaporated.

​

As a wedding party walked past us, she checked her phone.

​

“I’ve got a show tonight,” she said. “I have to go.”

​

We stood up and walked to the arch near the edge of the park.

​

“This was fun though,” she said as we hugged. “And thanks for not trying to kiss me.”

​

I watched her disappear down Fifth Avenue, then wandered down to West 8th and caught the A train home, still sweating even in the AC.

​

***

 

Two months after our first date, we were in bed when an audible boom cracked through the evening sky.

​

“What was that?” Roxanne asked, sitting upright, her knees still astride my hips. Her eyes flashed. “Did a bomb just drop on the town?”

​

I wrapped a towel around my waist and headed for the ladder.

​

Years ago, after my father died, I’d cut a hatch through the second-floor ceiling to watch the sun rise over Jamaica Bay up on the roof. I’d climb up there with coffee or bourbon, depending on the day, and feel suspended between sky and sea.

​

After the heart attack, when I inherited the house, I started rebuilding it with each freelance paycheck. Mold had bloomed in the walls since Hurricane Sandy when I took over the deed. Buckets still collected rainwater in three rooms. The central heat hadn’t worked since the Obama years. A belly stove blackened the first-floor ceiling. The water heater was dead. It was a husk with a view, a home in quotation marks, but a project nonetheless that I kept working on.

​

I hadn’t planned on bringing Roxanne here. It was not because of the distance from her Upper West Side studio or the home’s condition, but because Broad Channel was exactly who I was. Raw, wrecked, salty-boned, and laden with a secret history. I didn’t want her to see how far below the surface of normal I still lived, how much of myself I still concealed.

​

But she wanted to see where I came from, and I tried playing it cool.

​

Now, naked, we stood side by side on the roof, smoke rising from the vista point, cheers

echoing under moon light.
 

“It’s Demolition,” I said. “They brough it back after Trump.”

​

Her head tilted.

​

“What’s Demolition?”

​

“A Channel tradition,” I said. “It started in 88.’ They burn things they want to forget. Photos. Furniture. Old clothes. All of it inside an old burning car.”

​

“Therapy by fire?”

​

“Right.”

​

Another explosion burst, followed by cheering.

​

Roxanne’s eyes widened.

​

“Let’s go.”

​

“It’s probably wrapping up.”

​

She turned to me, still radiating with sweat, distant firelight tracing her collarbone.

​

“Come on. I’ve never seen anything like that. It’ll be original.”

​

“But you need something to throw in. That’s the point.”

​

She grinned. “I’ve got something.”

​

As we ducked back inside, and climbed down the ladder, I wondered if I was part of a character sketch. I wondered if Roxanne was playing the ingénue researching a play about redneck heartbreak. Perhaps I was just a prop.

​

Still, I grabbed an old photo album from under the bed.

​

Maven whined as we left. Her sidecar spot was being usurped. I told her we’d be back soon.

​

Roxanne laughed.

​

“Sorry, sweet girl,” as we shut the door.

​

She strapped on my extra helmet, goggles perched high, spinning once like a budding floret. I mounted the Harley. The engine bellyached to life, and we rolled down Cross Bay Boulevard.

​

We passed by the volunteer fire department and turned toward the Passion Pits, the old sandlot now turned into ritual grounds. A Mazda sedan burned at the center as we approached. Crime tape stretched from a birch tree to the firetruck’s bumper. I handed a couple of tens to the guards. Two Channelers I’d known since middle school. They nodded us through.

​

***

 

Demolition was already in full strike by the time we arrived. The Mazda was almost unrecognizable. Its engine howling in pain, paint curling in oily whorls, flames licking the roof like an infection.

​

Ash sifted down on us like confetti. Roxanne gripped my hand.

​

All around the blaze, Broad Channel had come alive. They called folks here Channel Rats and they yowled, hooted and jeered as they hurled memories into the inferno. Gasoline-soaked regrets, tossed into a ceremonial furnace, aiming for forgiveness.

​

“Compliments to the chef,” someone called.

​

I turned and saw Deon. He was a grade-school tormentor turned Port-O-John worker. He stood there in jorts, Jordans, a Mets jersey, and a red MAGA hat like it was part of a Queens Redneck kit.

​

“This is Roxanne,” I said.

​

He gave her a once-over.

​

“Welcome to the Channel,” he said. “We finally got Demolition back!”

​

He stumbled off, chasing the fumes and racket blasting.

​

“You said you had something to burn?” I asked.

​

Roxanne looked around. Her eyes grazed the crowd like a documentarian scoping a strange, half-extinct tribe. MAGA hats, jerseys, graphic tees, bedazzled hoodies. Photos of cheating spouses swirling in flame. Fake birds. Dog toys. A pair of snakes – possibly real – blackened and writhing in its sinister glare.

​

“They’re Tokens of Unappreciation,” I explained. “You throw in whatever you’re ready to be done with. The more symbolic, the better.”

​

She watched a guy in a puffy vest launch a TV remote into the car’s firestorms. Another tossed in a framed diploma. Someone else burned tax returns and a Teddy Ruxpin.

​

“That one’s carrying some shit,” she said.

​

McCambridge, a former roller hockey star who lost his SUNY Plattsburgh scholarship to a feverish coke habit, hurled a brand-new pair of Timbs in.

​

“It’s the final round!” bellowed a voice through a bullhorn.

​

“Fuck yeah,” Roxanne said, eyes vivid. She stepped forward.

​

“You gonna wait in line?” I asked.

​

“No,” she said.

​

She strutted to the front, unbuttoning her denim jacket as she strutted, blue firelight encircling her hair.

​

“My ex gave this to me!” she cried, holding it overhead. “And he’s a fucking Scientologist!”

​

Laughter heaved through the crowd. Some clapped. A few booed, and an elderly woman holding a cowboy hat groaned about her cutting the line.

​

She launched the jacket into the sedan. The denim soon erupted into blues and golds, spinning upward like a boozy comet.

​

I followed, holding the photo album. It was my wedding full of fake smiles and false promises. I didn’t even waver. I tossed it and watched pages crackle and fold into each other, memories searing into residue.

​

“Demolition for life!” Roxanne shouted.

​

Cheers swelled around her.

​

“One more kick!” the bullhorn hollered.

​

The two guards came and hurled Molotovs into the car. The sedan detonated in a boom so loud it shook my chest. People screamed with joy with their fists raised in a flare. Some danced around.

​

I stared into the smoldering mess, picturing my marriage as black powder lifting into the night sky. It felt like release.

​

When I turned back to Roxanne, her hands were on her throat – her face covered in soot, eyes wide and panicked.

​

***

 

It was our third date when we met for Negronis at the Algonquin bar, famous for its writerly souls – the bench-seated New York literati sect of a bygone era. I’d just finished covering the murder of a jogger in Howard Beach. She’d just played her hundredth performance in the Fanny Brice musical.

​

She arrived in a linen dress, cheeks still flushed from stage lights.

​

Over cocktails, we swapped stories. Mine revolving around the city’s latest murder victim, trial details, quarrels in the press pit. Hers traveled to new voiceover gigs, a movie script, and a shower-scene in her past that once tore her vocals.

​

“It gave me an identity crisis,” she said. “If I couldn’t sing, who was I?”

​

The voice returned, eventually. For six months, she said, it felt like a death.

​

Now her dream was to win a Tony before escaping to the Pacific Northwest, where she’d live on a goat farm and do community theater when it rained.

​

“I know it’s gauche to say I want the award,” she added, smiling sadly. “But it would be validating to win something.”

​

After drinks, we wandered Midtown, drenched in late-summer stickiness before taking the subway uptown to her studio.

​

“You want to come up for a glass?” she asked. “We’re not having sex.”

​

“Good,” I said. “I’m not that easy.”

​

She poured Chotes-du-Rhones into tumblers, lit a battery-powered candle, and set Coltrane on the speaker. The storm outside thump against the fire escape.

​

A black-and-white photo of her grandfather and Dennis Hopper hung on the fridge.  There was no couch or television. She had a mattress, a low desk, and a kitchen stocked with probiotics, Mitcher’s bourbon, and Manuka honey.

​

“Sorry about the sparseness,” she said. “I’m still moving in.”

​

“How long you been here?”

​

“Three years.”

​

We sat on the floor, cross-legged, like kids in a fort.

​

“Life is weird,” she said, staring out the window. “A few days ago, I didn’t know you existed. Now you’re in my apartment.”

​

“Hopefully you’re not a serial killer,” I said.

​

“Hopefully.”

​

We talked about places we wanted to disappear to in the world. She said Patagonia was her number one spot.

​

“That was fast.”

​

“It’s in Argentina and Chile. You’ve never heard of it?”

​

“No,” I admitted.

​

She asked me the same question.

​

“Socotra,” I said. “In Yemen. It’s an island with a 300-million-year-old species of tadpole shrimp. Living fossils. I want to see one.”

​

“You were waiting to tell someone that.”

​

“I was.”

​

Later, when I stood to leave, I told her.

​

“Time to get awkward.”

​

“I guess you’re going to kiss me now,” she said.

​

Her lips were indulgent and unguarded. My fingers brushed her cheek, and she pulled back slowly.

 

“No one’s ever touched my face like that,” she sighed.

​

There was something unspoken as if we’d met years prior.

​

That night, back in Queens, I saw her text:

​

Every heartache I’ve had is worth the promise you bring. And that scares me.

​

***
 

“I want to see where you’re from,” Roxanne said on our fourth date.

​

We were seated at a candlelit bar near her place uptown. She’d just told a neighboring couple we’d met at a hand-model audition in Sweden.

​

I must have winced. Not because of the lie – those now came easy – but because I didn’t want her to see Broad Channel.

​

The Channel wasn’t a neighborhood to me. It was a tainted history. A gravitational pull of bad choices lashed together on a low-lying spit of land that felt like its own crooked organism.

​

Half my sixth-grade class was dead or incarcerated. I had cigarette burn scars along my neck and shoulder. I was raised by a man who drank himself into heart failure, and a grandfather who drank himself into the ocean. The streets of the place reminded me.

​

But I smiled, staying unruffled.

​

“Sure,” I said.

​

In her apartment that night she asked why my energy was off.

​

“I’m fine,” I told her, undressing. She climbed onto me, and my anxieties slid out of reach for a while.

​

We made love in a kind of meditative trance. It was less like people falling and more like people trying to remember how to feel something again.

​

She dozed off in my arms while fake candlelight jittered across the ceiling.

​

***

 

Two nights later, Roxanne took the A train to Broad Channel. I met her at the Subway station, where marsh and sky met in muted gray. She stepped onto the platform in a sundress and ankle boots, eyes scanning the waterline.

​

“This is impossibly romantic,” she said.

​

I wasn’t sure if she meant the view or the isolation it provided.

​

I drove and we climbed out of my car and up to the house two stories overlooking the bay. She didn’t comment on the sagging porch or the buckets to catch leaking water. We went straight to the roof, where I set out homemade hummus and pita chips and a bottle of Malbec.

​

Roxanne talked about her show. Monday nights were always half-capacity, and the punchlines often fell flat due to all the foreign tourists not understanding the American references. She reenacted a few for me, throwing her hands beneath her chin like a starlet from a forgotten era when she finished. I laughed harder than necessary, nerves rattling.

​

She talked about her past lovers again. She called one an actor with an inflated ego disease and dead eyes. “It was all too performative. It was like he was dating himself,” she said.

​

“Good thing you picked someone egoless,” I said, raising a glass.

​

We stayed on the roof for hours drinking, smoking, slipping into and out of our clothes. The atmosphere fell from twilight to a murky blue shade poked by glowing stars. She spoke about her vegetarianism, her disdain for privilege. How, in the right time and place, she’d kill and eat a goat. “I’m not morally superior,” she said. “I’m just removed from the process.”

​

I understood she needed to speak. She was building a trust bridge between us, plank by plank. I let her talk because I was afraid of what might happen if she turned her scrutiny on me or the past I couldn’t rewrite, or the present I was barely surviving.

​

That was the night Demolition called us from the firmament.

​

***

 

After the fire, Roxanne’s throat closed up. By the next morning, her voice was gone.

​

The ER doctor said the cause was smoke inhalation. It was nothing permanent, but she’d need rest for weeks, perhaps months, depending on the time it took her to fully regain strength in her vocal cords. She burst into tears when she heard the news.

​

I stayed with her at the hospital overnight, holding her hand while monitors blinked their observation. She couldn’t speak, so we wrote notes back and forth on a legal pad. Her out of need, me out of solidarity.  Her mother was flying in from Los Angeles.

​

She asked: Why did that whole event feel Biblical?

​

I didn’t answer.

​

Your mother will be here when you wake up, I wrote.

​

I fell asleep after she nodded off.

​

The next morning, I kissed her sleeping forehead and said I had to work. She squeezed my hand and nodded.

​

But I didn’t go to work.

​

***

 

I took the train back to Broad Channel and sat on the roof, drinking from a bottle of Mitcher’s bourbon I’d stolen from her kitchen. The exposed sky throbbed with summer haze, and the bay looked like melted crystal. I couldn’t stop thinking about the soot on her face. The way she’d gripped her neck. The part of me that had watched it all without moving. The sniffles, the heart ache.

​

I didn’t text. I didn’t call.

​

Instead, I drifted for days that blurred to weeks. When she contacted me, I told her I was covering a murder in Far Rockaway or Sheepshead Bay or Baltimore. The lies came easy again. It was easier than showing up or being decent.

​

The drinking worsened and so did my absences on assignments. My editor pulled me aside to try to get me help one day, but I ignored his warning and was soon fired.

​

Meanwhile, Roxanne tried. She texted me and eventually left voicemails when her voice returned.

​

“Just come over,” she said two months after Demolition. “I don’t care what state you’re in.”

​

I was afraid she’d see me for what I was again. Instead of a reinvention, I was just an old rerun.

​

Eventually, her texts and calls stopped.

​

***

 

It took me years to reach back out to Roxanne after finding her on Facebook.

​

She had moved to Portland. She was married with two kids and lived in a home with a wraparound porch and chickens in the yard. When her voice returned, she’d acted in three films with Meryl Streep. She never won a Tony, but she didn’t need to. She became who she was always going to be.

​

As part of Step Nine, I sent her the initial message. I didn’t expect or deserve a reply. I just had to tell her: I know it doesn’t matter now, and it was a long time ago but I’m sorry. I was sick. I was afraid. I ruined something good.

​

She wrote back a week later.

​

I’m glad you’re okay, she said. I often wondered.

​

We traded a few messages that moved with cordial, warm, and elliptical rhythm. She told me she missed performing sometimes. I told her I didn’t miss journalism, and PR was not as bad as I thought it would be. I left out the part about getting kicked out of journalism or all the relapses.

​

Suddenly, she asked: Why did you go missing when I needed you most?

​

I stared at the blinking cursor.

​

I wanted to write about the shame. The way I felt in the ER that night or the muck inside my chest that never went away. How terrified I was of loving her because she made me trust in a life I didn’t deserve.

 

I wanted to write something true.

​

Instead, I sat there, watching the screen, not typing anything at all.

 

​

​​​By Henrick Karoliszyn

Henrick Karoliszyn is writer based in New Orleans. His fiction was selected by the Ernest Hemingway Foundation and published in the 2025 Hemingway Shorts literary anthology, shortlisted for The Letter Review Prize, and a finalist for the 2026 Kurt Vonnegut Speculative Fiction Prize (results pending). His work has also been featured in McSweeney's Internet Tendency, Flash Fiction Magazine, and ExPat Press along with forthcoming editions of BULL and Blood+Honey literary magazines. He's at work on his debut short story collection and a novel.

​

X: Henrick_AK

The Balladeer's Apprentice

​​​​

​​​The Balladeer heard the world through song. He heard chord progressions in the icy waves that crashed along the Ballyshane shoreline. He heard lyrics in the chirping birds that skittered from the rain-soaked pastures of Kilbrittain for sunnier real estate far from home. He heard rhythm in the turning carriage wheels and the horse hoof clicks on the dusty country roads. Perhaps that’s why he never fussed much over being alone, because no matter how lonely he may have seemed, the music of the world was close by to keep him company.

 

When he was a younger man, he traveled the rural landscape of southern Ireland with little more than a topcoat and a guitar. There wasn’t a pub in County Cork where the innkeeper didn’t know his name. The townsfolk knew of the Balladeer, too. They came to his performances for the bittersweet ballads and stayed because they were drawn to his handsome features. He had wild copper hair, a neatly trimmed beard, and eyes that possessed the romantic quality of a philosopher’s stare. Though the Balladeer would be the first to say that it’s not only the look of a man that tells his story.

 

There was poetry in his fingerpicking, and such a spirit in his lyricality, that when one heard him perform, it was impossible to walk away without feeling forever changed. When he took to song, even the veterans of the Great War, hardened by nightmares of the trenches, couldn’t help but open the locked doors of their hearts and well up with ancient tears they’d try to hide behind their rough hands. When he was on stage with a guitar on his knee, his attention appeared to be elsewhere, on a rain-soaked windowpane or on a melancholy widow sitting alone and nursing a sherry. It was this balance of intimacy and distance that charmed so many of the country girls who came to hear him play. They locked in on his every note, only shifting their focus from the man to whisper giggled adorations to the other girls at their table.

 

During one such performance, the Balladeer couldn’t take his own eyes off a country girl who was sitting with her friends in a booth off in the back. As he finished, “Follow Me up to Carlow,” he found himself staring at the woman while she sipped her drink. Hoping to refocus, he quickly started into another ballad. But then she brushed her dark hair from her face and their eyes met. His hands went clammy. His pulse quickened. With that thump thumping, he felt his heart would explode right through his chest. Flustered, he lost the tune of the performance. He stopped his guitar and let his eyes wander over the audience. “I’m sorry, folks,” he apologized. “Lost my place, I guess.”

​

Deidre blushed. She enjoyed watching the boy struggle. She further enjoyed that she was the source of his struggle. She straightened out her auburn work dress and approached the stage. “Could you play The Fields of Athenry?” she asked him.

​

Her voice was a fresh melody, a song the Balladeer had never heard before. He lost his words. And though he tried to settle himself, he couldn’t take his eyes off the heavy crimson of her soft lips.

​

“Are you in there, lad?” she asked with a smile that possessed a knowledge of his unspoken affection.

 

“I’m sorry, miss,” he was finally able to say with a little crack in his voice.

​

She returned to her friends. He played the song. Once it was over, she offered the Balladeer a polite nod in appreciation. After his set was over, Deidre sat beside him at the bar and offered him a pint. The pair sat in conversation for a while in the romantic glimmer of the firelight until the barman began closing up for the night.

​

“May I walk you home?” the Balladeer asked while helping the barman collect dirty glasses.

​

“You may.”

​

They walked along Church Square, arm in arm, under a thumbnail moon. Finding a bench beside the park, they sat close together, and each confessed they were orphans. They each confessed they were eager to begin their real lives. They each confessed they were dreamers.

​

“I hope to see America,” she whispered. “Like my younger sister, the actress.”

​

“I hope to have a family,” he whispered. “I never got to have one of those.”

​

They spoke their dreams in whispers, fearful that too loud a voice would prevent them from coming true. For hours in the crisp darkness of an Irish autumn, they spoke of their futures behind the tune of night crickets until the sun rose over Charles Fort. 

​

***

​

A marriage and a baby they called Jack, soon followed. They found a small cottage not far from town with strong stone walls, a sizable hearth, and a couple of simple rooms. It wasn’t much, but the place had its own melody. The way the strong winds rattled the shutters, the way the floorboards creaked and croaked with each heavy step, the way the crackle of the fire popped and whined.

​

It was a humble existence, no doubt, but the Balladeer never asked for more than his worth. The only luxury he allowed himself was a small library of second-hand poetry that would kickstart his heart when the writing got tough. And anyway, all he really needed, he said, was a warm fire and a song. He played for Deidre and Jack in the mornings by that warm fire when the fresh sun spilled in through the small window to the east. With a hot coffee beside him, he tinkered with new ballads while Deidre hummed along and the baby offered little coos of approval.

​

Just as they all began settling into the pleasures of domestic life, Deidre’s sister in America fell ill. With her parents gone, the obligation to care for her sister was just too strong to ignore. The Balladeer hurried to pull together all their humble savings for passage across the Atlantic. Two tickets were all he could manage. The decision was made that Deidre and Jack would go first. The Balladeer would gig through the cold winter, save what he could, and meet them by spring.

​

At the shipyards, Deidre was bundled in her heavy red pea coat with a green tweed scarf wrapped around her neck. As she cradled baby Jack in her arms, she whispered her goodbyes to the Balladeer.

 

“Don’t cry, love. I’ll be seeing you before you know it,” she said, trying to comfort him while nestling herself into his open arms. He squeezed her tightly, unable to find his voice. She stepped back and looked him over. Her eyes went wide with a sudden fear that he might run off on her like so many of the other husbands in town who lost themselves to drink and untethered women once the children arrived.

 

The Balladeer sensed her trouble. He blew warm breath into the cupped palms of his fingerless gloves. “No need to worry. We’ll be back together again before you know it,” he whispered. He gave them each a kiss that eased Deidre’s nerves and said, “Safe journey, my dear ones.”

 

But back in those days, there was no such thing as a safe journey. Fare thee well, too often meant forever.

​

The storm came on fast. The ship took on water. And all were lost.

​

When he heard the news, the music of the Balladeer’s world was suddenly silenced.

​

He barely left the cottage after that. When he did venture out, he never spoke to anyone and kept his eyes firmly affixed on the ground, fearful that the sight of a sympathetic eye would cause him to break down in the street. His waking mind was full of nightmares, dense with grotesque illusions of how Deidre and Jack violently left this world. So he boarded up the window to the east, desperate to put those visions to rest and feed his gluttony for sleep. In his dreams, he willed himself to seek out an untarnished memory of Deidre and Jack. After months, she came to him in such a dream and chastised him for his childish mourning.

​

“Enough of this moping,” she scolded. “It’s time to get on with your life now. See, I’ll be wanting you to sing for us when we meet again. You mustn’t get rusty.”

​

The Balladeer heeded Deidre’s commandment and set back into the world. Wandering the landscape of his grief, he made his way from gig to gig like a man lost in a fog. People couldn’t help but see that the man had changed. His hair had grown long and gray. His clear blue eyes, once as riotous as the Irish Sea, had turned dark and cold.

​

One night, he was playing at his favorite pub called The Queen Jane. It was intimate and dark: all stone and wood. The Balladeer loved it so because the barback kept the fires burning and the lights down dim. When he was on stage with the gentle firelight before him, the place almost felt like the home where he’d play for Deidre and Jack. Following his set, he was at the bar looking after his third pint when a young boy, no older than 20, approached him with a fresh ale and a smile.

​

“You were great up there,” the boy said.

 

“Thanks much, lad,” the Balladeer replied.

 

“I was wondering if you’d train me,” the boy said hesitantly, “if you do that kind of thing.”          

 

“I’m sorry, no. I don’t,” the Balladeer said.

 

“I can pay you, sir,” the boy said with a desperate quiver in his voice. He pushed the ale toward the Balladeer.

​

Sipping his beer, the Balladeer quietly looked the boy over. His dark hair was floppy, and he had acne pocks on the stubble of his chin. His posture was slouched, and his trousers were too large for his lean frame. In all, the boy appeared fragile, as if he might break at any moment.

 

“Tell me, boy,” the Balladeer said. “What do you know of loss?”

 

The boy, Patrick was his name, went on to tell the Balladeer his own tragic story. “My father was executed in the War. After my poor mother heard the news, she walked around like she was lost in the daylight, staring at the walls for hours without a word. She passed shortly after. The doctor said it was a broken heart,” Patty said. “Never quite understood that. Dying of a broken heart. When you lose someone you love that much, it’s more than your heart that breaks, ain’t it?”

​

The Balladeer knew it was. Underneath the boy’s plain language, he could hear a shiver of grief. He could hear a song. He was then struck by a sudden responsibility to help the boy give voice to his hurt. “Tuesdays and Thursdays at my cottage outside of town,” he instructed, running a hand through his wild, gray hair. “We play before the sun sets.” The Balladeer said no more, returning to his fourth pint in the hopes that drink might silence the agony of his despair.

​

The boy arrived at the cottage prepared to play the role of the steadfast student. He tapped his knuckles timidly on the door. The Balladeer invited the boy in. He sat in his armchair, the one by the fireplace where Deidre nursed baby Jack. Patty sat beside him on a small stool that wobbled when he shifted his weight with the excitement of learning something new. The Balladeer picked up his guitar, the one with the wood worn at the neck. Patty closely observed his teacher while he demonstrated a chord.

​

“You see?” the Balladeer asked.

​

Patty didn’t see. He struggled with all of it. His finger positions were off, his chord progressions were clunky, and like the town’s taxman, he couldn’t arrive at the figurative logic of a well-placed metaphor. In short, the boy labored mightily with the language of music, but to his credit, he was quite the student. He arrived at their sessions early and did as he was told. He listened intently to his teacher and took notes with a shaved-down pencil nub in order not to forget what they’d covered. After leaving the cottage, he’d continue his studies, drafting ballads late into the night, when all the gas lamps along Sligo Street still flickered with the romance of midnight’s quiet temper.

​

After two years of persistent study, Patty was able to find small gigs around the village. A church fundraiser here. A pub or two there. He never packed them in like the Balladeer, but given the boy’s reputation as a bit of a lost cause, his competence made his teacher seem all the more impressive. So much so that another young man came calling, seeking out the Balladeer after a performance at the Wexford Inn.

​

“Daniel O’Sullivan, they call me.”

 

“How can I help you, Danny?” the Balladeer asked softly.

 

“I want to learn. Like Patty.”

 

“I’m done with all that, I’m afraid,” the Balladeer said, sipping his tea. It wasn’t that he didn’t enjoy his work with Patty. He did. Though he found that the more he taught the boys, the less he performed, and he reasoned that he was a balladeer, not a teacher. The man couldn’t help but feel that the farther away he got from the stage, the more he became a stranger in his own skin.

 

“Please, sir,” Danny begged.

​

The Balladeer saw that Danny had a face the girls in town would find easy to love. He had neatly trimmed amber hair and long sideburns that would’ve paired nicely with a beard if he could’ve grown one, which he couldn’t. He owned broad farming shoulders and wore clothing wrought for wear. The boy’s strength was impossible to ignore, though there was an uncertainty in his eyes, like he wasn’t sure whether he belonged in his own story.

​

The Balladeer gave a polite nod and asked, “Tell me, what do you know of loss?”

 

Danny sighed. “My girl, Shannon. She left me right for another fella.” He cleared his throat and wiped a tear with the back of his hand. “I just wish I could see her one last time, is all. Hear her voice. Smell her perfume. So I can remember it all, you know?”

​

The Balladeer did know. Even though it had been years since he lost his family, he still slept under sheets of sorrow. In his dreams, he slipped into phantom memories of Sunday suppers that never were. In his dreams, he played songs for the ghosts of his wife and child over tea and biscuits by the fire. In his dreams, his family would bundle up in the winter and trudge down Butcher’s Row for an evening out at the cinema.

​

It was this shared sense of lost love that swayed the Balladeer to take Danny on, though he promised himself the boy would be his final student. Thankfully, it all came easier for Danny. The Balladeer didn’t need to spend an hour in demonstration with him as he did with poor Patty, and he quickly came to look forward to their time together.

​

Following a year of study, Danny had become a fine musician with the pen of a poet.

​

“You’re ready, Danny,” the Balladeer said to him after a lesson as Danny was packing up his guitar.

​

“You think?”

​

“I do.”

​

Audiences came in droves to admire his fit frame, to witness his strong hands delicately pluck at his guitar strings, and to listen to his original ballads. Performance after performance, word of Danny’s skill spread. Within a few months, all that acclaim brought another hopeful young man to the Balladeer’s door.

​

It was early morning when Finnegan arrived at the Balladeer’s cottage with a brand-new guitar in a velvet-lined leather case. He was dolled up in a gray three-piece suit and standing in shiny new shoes that were slightly muddied from his trek out of town. His hair was black as soot, tightly parted, and wet with oil. The boy banged crassly on the cottage door with a closed fist. When the Balladeer opened up, he was still in his robe and bed slippers. He wearily wiped the sleep from his eyes and asked, “And you are?”

​

“I’m called Finnegan. I’m here for my lesson,” the young man commanded, rubbing a thumb over his clean-shaven chin.

 

The Balladeer looked the boy over with his fancy suit, his fancy shoes, and his expensive new guitar. He’d seen dozens of boys like him over the years. They’d bound into the pubs on the posh side of town with their chests puffed out and their muscles half-flexed. Such a well-to-do boy would know nothing of loss, only of gain, and thus he felt no need to take the young man on.

​

“I’m done with all that, I’m afraid,” the Balladeer explained politely.

 

The boy flashed a wry grin, stuck a thumb in his jacket pocket, and launched into a sob story about his folks going down on the Titanic, about his true love falling asleep on a church pew during mass and never waking, about his dog Clover running off into the dark of the Ballyregan night never to return. Sob story after sob story, he spoke with such conviction that he was almost able to mask the rancid odor of his bullshit.

​

“I don’t believe you, Finnegan,” the Balladeer said sternly. “I don’t believe a word of it.”

​

“Well, it’s all true,” Finnegan said, doubling down on his lies as young men are wont to do.

 

“No, it isn’t. Here’s the first rule of Balladeers. Your job is to make them believe. Not only in their minds, but in here,” the Balladeer explained, touching Finnegan’s chest.

​

“Yeah, yeah. Look’it, I need a teacher old-timer, and you’re the best.”

 

The Balladeer looked the boy over again. He was pompous; there was no doubt about that, and blessed with that easy confidence which so often accompanies the monied.

​

It would’ve been easy to dismiss the boy because of his privilege. And in truth, the Balladeer spent a hard moment considering such a dismissal. But then, he wondered, why shouldn’t such a boy get an education? Why should a man’s wealth prohibit such a thing? He held his stare on the boy’s smirk of superiority. He is a foolish child, the Balladeer reasoned, without a lesson, he’ll never learn.

​

So the Balladeer took him on. It wasn’t easy, but teaching never is. The self-importance of young Finnegan irked him to no end, but he did well to hide his disdain from the boy. After their first few lessons together, he became so sick with shame for further boosting Finnegan’s ego that he doubled his confessional visits with Father Attaway. He even wrote a ballad about their time together called The Serpent’s Last Song.

​

As much as it pained the Balladeer to admit it, there was no doubt that Finnegan had the gift. He never told him this, of course, but the speed and precision of his finger-picking was like watching a sleight-of-hand magician, and his turn of phrase in songwriting rivaled the Balladeer’s.

​

For his part, Finnegan liked to keep the lessons short and had a knack for stealing the Balladeer’s best bars to repurpose them for his own tunes. At the end of each session, he’d slip in subtle slights meant to harm the old man and inflate his own worth. Things like, “Maybe next time a challenge, Pops.”

 

Their last lesson came shortly before the chill of December turned the greens of the plains gray with season. The Balladeer sat quietly while Finnegan played him The Auld Triangle. The Balladeer had heard the song a thousand times before, maybe more, but not like this. He nearly lost his breath. He placed his wrinkled hand over his heart. Finnegan looked up from his guitar. When he noticed his teacher’s awe, he stopped playing mid-chorus, flashed a cocky grin, and packed away his pricey guitar. Then he left the cottage, walking out into the cold, without a word of consolation for the grief he may have caused his teacher or a word of thanks for the time he’d gifted.

 

Word of Finnegan’s talents made its way through the countryside. Soon, the pubs were too small to hold his devoted numbers. Even the churches couldn’t contain his fans who’d flock into town when news of Finnegan’s arrival was posted. The Balladeer heard that the boy had given up the lavish suits, ditched his fancy shoes, and began performing with a four-string guitar that he had sanded over and stained to give it the impression of an instrument that belonged to one who’d suffered. He heard rumors that the boy played with ripped trousers, a stained white blouse, and a corduroy coat with a tweed flap cap. Despite all the games and deceptions, the Balladeer harbored no ill will toward the boy because he knew that if Finnegan lived long enough, he’d learn.

​

As the years passed, the Balladeer unboarded that small window to the east to allow for the morning sun to return. The torment of Deidre and Jack’s absence was still there, but it had become more of a smolder than the destructive bonfire it once was. The man had grown so weary with age that when he picked up his guitar and tried to play, his arthritic hands locked up on him. He played less and less and stopped performing. He missed the stage, but oddly enough, what he missed most of all was his lessons with Patty, Danny, and even the arrogant Finnegan.

 

One day, as the frosts of winter thawed and the spring wildflowers began to bloom in the meadow beside the Balladeer’s cottage, he was roused by a soft rapping on the door. The old man opened up and laid his tired eyes on Finnegan. The man looked a shell of his former self, deflated, with his limp arms dangling by his side. He had changed.

​

“Come on in,” the Balladeer said, wrapping his robe around his gaunt waist.

​

Finnegan slumped into the room, slouched down onto his student stool, and laid his guitar gently on the floor by his feet. The Balladeer placed a few dry logs in the hearth and lit the fire. He sat in his chair beside Finnegan and waited. He waited for the snarky boasts. He waited for the riotous exaggerations of his own accomplishments. He waited for the privileged put-downs. But they never came. Instead, Finnegan unsnapped his guitar case and removed the instrument. While he was tuning the thing, he struggled to meet the Balladeer’s eye.  

​

Finnegan cleared his throat and played a new ballad for his teacher. The Balladeer paid it a respectful listen, trying to ignore the memories of all the hurtful words directed his way. The song seemed to be about the great famine, but the Balladeer could see through the framing metaphor. He could tell it was about lost love. It was perhaps the saddest thing the Balladeer had ever heard. When the hum of the stringed vibration came to rest, he allowed the song to settle inside him for a beat. Finally, he placed a hand on Finnegan’s shoulder and asked, “Was it your parents?”

​

Finnegan was unable to give voice to his grief. The Balladeer, feeling the familiar pull of that nostalgic anguish, didn’t push the issue. He only went on to say, “Well, it’s a beautiful song, Finnegan.”

​

Something about hearing the Balladeer say his name set Finnegan off. He lost what little strength he still possessed, hunched over, and wept into his hands while struggling to tell the story through his muffled tears. “My wife. My child. Smallpox,” was the breadth of what the Balladeer could make of it.

​

There was nothing the Balladeer could say to heal such a fresh wound; he’d learned that one has to live with it. Eventually, the anguish would feel like another limb; it would just be there. Picking up own his guitar from beside the hearth, he asked, “How about we play one together, son?”

​

The Balladeer’s apprentice uncurled himself, wiped away his tears, and held tight to his guitar. “I’d like that,” he said. “Thank you,” he said. Then he leaned over to help tune his teacher’s guitar and rested his own on his knee. Together, they strummed up a melody. They hummed along a wordless chorus. They sat for hours by that fire, tweaking the rhyme and tinkering with the chords. They’d hit a wall, fail, regroup, and then fail again. By the time the morning sun whispered through the cottage window, the two men had finished the song. They called it The Balladeer’s Apprentice. Both men would admit toward the end of their own stories that the song was their finest, though neither of them ever played it for another soul.

​​

​​

​By Jeremy Stelzner

Jeremy Stelzner’s stories have appeared in numerous literary magazines, journals, and anthologies, including the 2024 Coolest American Stories, the McNeese Review, and Prime Number Magazine, where his story The Thin Line was awarded runner-up for the 2024 Press 53 Award for Short Fiction. He’s a teacher of literature and journalism.

​

Website: www.jastelzner.com

Email: jeremystelzner71@gmail.com

Blue Moon

​​​

When I think about you, the first thing I think of is Blue Moon. Not the original, or the covers by Elvis, Sinatra, Cyndi or The Beatles, but the one by The Marcels. Our fifth-year teacher had a fascination with rock and roll dancing and once a week he’d take us away from class to teach us how to swing in the school hall to the slow, deliberate beat of Blue Moon. The hall was really a large shed with plywood walls and uncomfortable wooden pews for the seniors to sit on as we huddled on the rolled out carpets for assembly, where it quickly became unbearably hot with the few hundred people of the school inside. He’d line us up against the walls, boys on one side, girls on the other. The awkward energy between the two lines would have been enough to power a small substation.​

​

I’m not sure how we ended up paired together, you were at least a head shorter than me, but the girls in our class did tend to fall on the smaller side. You’d blown into town at the start of the year so I knew very little about you. The only interaction we’d had together was when I’d nearly ran you over with my BMX on the way to school. The teacher guided us through how to hold each other; left hands clasped together, my right on the small of your back, yours on my shoulder. We took to the moves like it was something we had been doing all of our lives while the other kids around us stumbled over each other’s feet or were brought to fits of laughter by the singer’s tone of voice. After the dance was over we barely acknowledged each other and made our way back to our usual places in the class, but it was the start of something that would define my year.

​

The other thing I remember about that time is that was when you first started digging in the pit. Calling it a pit was generous; it was really just a pile of gravel overlooking the soccer fields at the back of the school, but it seemed like in a pit in that way that everything seems bigger than it is when you’re knee high to a tree stump. One day I spotted you sitting in the pit, poking at the dirt with a stick.

​

“Hi,” I said, approaching gingerly.

​

“Hi,” you replied, our interactions still awkward and fledgling.

​

“What are you doing?” I asked.

​

“Digging for stuff, do you want to join in?” You asked as you held a second stick my way.

​

Wordlessly I sat down next to you and began chipping away at the loosely packed pile of stone until I spotted something shiny sticking out. Pulling it out revealed it to be a badly weathered and broken piece of what was once a plastic school ruler. Naturally I showed the discovery to my friends once we got back to class and very quickly, my friend group became your friend group too.

​

Our yet to be stifled senses of imagination told us the pit was an archaeological site where we could dig up forgotten remnants of the school’s past. In reality it was one of those lunchtime distractions that we would be barred from in a month after someone took things too far. Last month that distraction had been playing bullrush on the field below us until a kid got tackled a little too hard and had to go home early, the month before that it had been trading Pokémon cards at the lunchtime benches until they started getting pinched from backpacks.

​

Having been the first explorers of the pit, the two of us became impromptu foremen, ordering our fellow classmates on what to dig for and where. With our increasing numbers, we began making real progress at chipping though the pit, wiping sweat from our brows as we kneeled on the pale, dusty ground in the punishing sunlight. However, aside from a sharp piece of China plate, no other discoveries had been made. The lack of results meant our numbers began to wane, as kids looked for something else to spend their lunchtimes doing that didn’t involve choking on dust.

​

One day though, once our party had been reduced to a few stragglers with nothing better to do, you found something shiny glinting out at you. I and the handful of other remaining diggers gathered around as you scratched away around the shiny something. Pulling it out and dusting it off it looked like a jagged pebble, but it was ever so slightly blue and caught the sunlight in the most fascinating way when held up. I thought it could have been glass, but it didn’t cut you when you turned it over and ran your fingers over it to examine its perfectly smooth faces.

​

“Gimmie! Gimmie! Let me have a look!” said Angus – the biggest, loudest kid in class – as he pushed the other kids out of the way to try and wrench the stone from your grasp.

 

“Yaz found it Angus. She gets to hold it,” I told him, getting between you and him.

When other kids started coming to the pit, we had established three rules to hopefully prevent catching the ire of the patrolling duty teachers. One: No fighting. Two: You have to use a stick to dig. Three: Finders keepers.

 

“She should share though. It’s not fair!” He said in protest, kicking up a cloud of dust as he stomped his foot with every word.

​

Before the argument could escalate the bell rang, though the sound of it was soft this far away from the school buildings. You continued to hold the stone close, gazing down at it intermittently as we trekked back across the grass, and naturally when we got back you showed your discovery to the teacher. As his eyes adjusted to what you were holding between your finger and thumb, his expression changed ever so subtly from surprise to shock.

 

“Wow… That is quite the find there Yaz. Do you mind if I take it for just a second?”

 

A fellow child looking to wrench something from your grasp was very different to an adult in a position of authority politely asking to borrow it, so you handed it over without a second thought.

 

“Thank you,” he said with a smile before telling the rest of the class he’d be back quickly and disappearing out the door. From my usual seat by the window I could see he was heading towards the principal’s office.

​

Eventually he returned, the stone no longer in his hands. You didn’t have a chance to ask where it was as he wrangled us into a line and took us off to the school hall, it was time for another dance lesson.

​

“Alright everyone, find your partners and enough space to move around,” he said as he made for the CD player in the backroom.

 

Todays was a little different though, instead of teaching us a new dance he held an informal competition to see which of us were the best. We found each other and our hands found their places as if on instinct before the music started playing. Of course, the song the teacher picked was Blue Moon. We repeated the moves with grace while the teacher moved between pairs. The kids with no sense of rhythm were tapped on the shoulder and told to sit down, swiftly followed by the ones for whom holding hands was too uncomfortable to bear. The class was whittled down one pair at a time, but each time he passed us, he gave us a slight nod of approval before moving on. Eventually as the song was coming to its end it came down to us and one other pair. I dared not look at the other pair, lest I lose my place on the beat, so kept my eyes locked to yours as we swung and swayed. As the song played its final notes the teacher came to stand beside us. I guessed he was about to tell us to take our seats.  

 

“I think we have our winners,” he said instead, gesturing to us.

​

The class and our final opponents applauded us as we looked at each other with pleasant surprise, it seemed we made a good pair.

​

As we were leaving the hall, you tugged on the teacher’s sleeve to ask where the stone was.

 

“I gave it to the principal to look at,” he said, “he was as interested in it as I was and wanted to give it a proper inspection.”

 

“When will I get it back?” you asked.

 

“Soon Yaz I promise, we just think you may have found something special and want to know for sure.”

 

There was not much else we could do. We were just kids after all; it’s not like we could have barged into the principal’s office and taken it. Instead, you were asked to come to the office after a few days. You asked if I could come along, guessing what it was about and telling the teacher I had as much to do with finding the stone as you did, but the teacher said the principal only wanted to speak to you. I watched from the window as you made your way towards the office, your head down and hands balled into fists. My stomach began to tie itself in increasingly complex sailor knots even though I was pretty sure neither of us had done anything wrong. It wasn’t like we stole anything; it seemed like the stone had never belonged to anyone to begin with. At lunch I found you at the pit, which was now more popular than ever thanks to your discovery.  As kids crowded around from all angles and picked at the dirt like it was a great big scab, you told me what happened with the principal.

 

“He’s got some guy in to run tests on the stone, they think it’s a diamond.”

 

“A what?” asked Angus, eavesdropping on us from nearby.

 

“It’s like a really special rock or something, like that shiny Venasaur you had, he thinks it’s worth a lot of money,” you said in reply.

 

“Woah! We’re rich!” Cried out a delighted Angus, the rest of the group chattering excitedly.

 

“Did you get it back?” I asked you.

 

You shook your head; your face creased in a frown as it had been ever since the stone had been taken from you.

​

***

 

The next day, two men from the newspaper came to school, a tall, hairy man with glasses and a short, bald man with none. We were in class when the teacher asked you to go meet the two for a ‘photo op'. The day after the story was on the front page of the paper:

 

‘Lunchtime antics lead to primary school uncovering diamond worth millions,’ said the headline.

 

Under the title was a picture of you with two men, one was the principal but the other I didn’t recognise. He was a man with dark hair, a similarly dark suit, wide, round eyes and a big, toothy grin. Both he and the principal were beaming with pride holding the diamond aloft with a hand each – as if they were the ones who found it – with their other hands on your shoulders. While those two smiled your face bore the same frown you’d had for the last few days, it seemed the day you’d get your stone back was getting further and further away.

 

After the story came out new people started coming to school, led by the man in the dark suit. At first they came in trucks like what my dad drove but as more and more men arrived the trucks and machinery they drove got larger and larger. We came out to lunch one day to not only find the pit taped off, but most of the soccer fields too, the various contraptions and faceless men in safety equipment trampling the grass into muck. Over by the pit I spotted the man in the black suit directing the group, a high visibility jacket and hard hat placed over his usual outfit. Most of our digging group simply migrated back to the playground – which was now so crowded you had to wait minutes to go down the slide – but me and you leant on the tape and watched as the men brought out stranger and stranger equipment and the hole in the middle of the fields grew larger and larger. The weather became colder and damper. Clouds rolled in, obscuring the mountain in the distance from view. It would not reveal itself again for many months.

 

“This situation will only be temporary. I have advised these men to do their work in a way that will disturb us the least. They’re work will only last until the end of the school year and I think that by then we’ll have something very exciting to announce to you all,” said the principal at assembly, he too now having abandoned his smart casual clothes for a suit, although his was bright white. The audience, both children and school staff, seemed somewhat bewildered by what he’d said.

 

Despite the principal’s promises, there were many times class was interrupted by din of the machines incessant grinding and scraping and smashing as the field was turned from a large hole to a gaping chasm. Some teachers took classes on field trips on a near daily basis to get away from the constant, maddening noise. Most kids now spent their lunchtimes inside to stay safe from barrage of machines turning the grounds of the school into a foul-smelling slurry of mud, fuel and waste. The newspaper published concerns from local environmental groups that the toxic sludge from the dig could wash down the hill the school was perched on to the river at the bottom, but they too were drowned out by army of machines which appeared more monstrous by the day.

 

On the night of the end of year school disco, there was barely enough room on the road for my parents to drive me to school. Inside the hall the disco was different. Usually the space was mostly barren, save for a small stage against the back wall and a snack table off to the side as a selection of top 40 hits from five years ago blared from the tinny CD player. Tonight, streamers fluttered from the rafters and a light-up dancefloor was placed over the top of the usual plywood. In the place of the usual CD player, a DJ was spinning a mix of the current pop bangers. The principal welcomed me in, his strangely perfect, strangely wide smile was as luminescent as his suit. I tried to remember if his teeth had always been that white or if I’d just never seen them up close. The snack table was where it had always been but instead of Bluebird chips they had Copper Kettles, instead of no-name chocolate there were Whittakers and organic colas replaced the store-brand bottles of fizzy which had always vaguely tasted of soap. The environment projected such an aura of luxury that even the air inside smelt fresher than before, free of the halls usual lingering hint of mothballs and the stench of diesel outside.

 

However, despite the opulent surroundings, there still seemed to be a forcefield in the middle of the dancefloor separating the boys from the girls. Much like that first dance lesson, I kept my back to the wall and stared out at the other side of the hall with the rest of the boys until eventually you came over, dressed in a sparkling blue ball gown.

 

“Monique and Kyle are going to dance together; do you want to go to?”

 

Before I could answer you grabbed my hand and pulled me to a corner of the hall away from the bright lights and the prying eyes. Waiting for us was the second-place couple from the dance contest. In the time since then they had officially become a couple, or as much of a couple as you could be at our age. The two were already dancing by the time we arrived, our hands finding their usual spots on each other’s bodies.

 

“Wait,” I said. “What about the music?”

 

At that moment the DJ was playing some unholy mash up of The Pussycat Dolls and The Backstreet Boys. None of us were brave enough to ask the for a request, and even if we were, I doubted he’d have one of the songs we danced to on rotation.

 

“Just think of Blue Moon and look at me,” you said.

 

As I stared into the dark brown pools of your eyes, the music and surrounding ambience of the disco faded away, replaced by the droning voice of Cornelius Harp. I felt the beat in my head and led us on our slow, lazy circles. We could have been dancing there for hours, and I wouldn’t have known as we stared into each other’s souls. I marvelled at how your blue dress twinkled like the blue diamond you’d dug out. The world outside that square meter of plywood ceased to exist. In reality we could have only been there for a couple of minutes before I stopped to wipe the sweat of my hands, you must have registered that as the time to stop as your hands returned to your sides.

 

“Thanks for the dance,” you said, as we had been instructed to in class.

 

“You’re welcome,” was all I could say before you quickly walked away and out of the building.

 

I stood there for a moment, considering what just happened and though I didn’t realise it at the time, it was one of a handful of perfect moments any given person gets in their lives.  

 

***

 

Unfortunately, those perfect moments are as fragile as they are illusive. Arriving back at school the next week, I could tell something was off. The massive machines still occupied the fields, but the men were nowhere to be seen and the air around the grounds crackled with anxiety which wasn’t out of the ordinary but instead of coming from the children, it was coming from the adults. Once we were all in class, the teacher revealed the source of the angst. Someone had snuck into the principal’s office and stolen the diamond.

 

“We don’t know who it was, the Police are yet to be notified, but if the person who did it is in this room, the principle has told me that if you come clean and give it back, there will be no further action taken,” he said.

 

Most of the class murmured to themselves and looked at each other to see if anyone looked particularly guilty, but from my seat I noticed Angus staring bullets into the back of your head. It didn’t take long after we got let out for lunch for him to catch up with us. I’d taken you to the old playground to talk about what happened at the disco when he found us, his eyes full of rage and finger pointed accusingly at you.

 

“It was you! You stole it!” He shouted at you, getting too close for comfort.

 

“What are you talking about?” you asked.

 

“The Diamond! I saw you sneaking towards the principal’s office during the disco. If you don’t tell him right now, I will.”

 

“Stop it Angus,” I said, trying to stop the situation from escalating. “Yaz was dancing with me at the disco, it couldn’t have been her.”

 

“Don’t cover for her! You’ve been making love eyes at her for weeks but when I tell the principal your girlfriend is a thief that’ll be the last time you see her.”

 

Angus said this with a degree of malice that had me fearing what would happen next. Unfortunately, you didn’t feel that same fear.

 

“Angus, just because you didn’t find the diamond doesn’t mean you can bully me into saying I did something I–”

 

Angus moved so fast I couldn’t do anything about stopping him. The slap reverberated across the school grounds to the point nearby students craned their necks to see what had happened. The shock of it had knocked you to the ground. You didn’t cry, not at first but I could see tears forming in your eyes. It seemed Angus was surprised by his own actions, as his eyes were wide and mouth agape, his arm still outstretched. Any attempt from me to calm everyone down went out the window as all I could see through the red mist was my hurt friend and the person who hurt her. I was on Angus before he could do anything about it and my hands rained down with all the pre-pubescent fury I could muster. The commotion and Angus’ wailing caught the attention of several roaming teachers, and they eventually hauled me off the weeping Angus before dragging us all to the principal’s office.

 

***

 

“Sir, all I did was ask Yaz if she’d seen the diamond cause I knew it meant a lot to her, and he attacked me,” Angus said, pointing a finger at me and getting his accusation out between heaving sobs. I sat there silently shaking with my eyes on the floor, in slight disbelief at my own violent actions, thankfully you stood up for me.

​

“That’s not true sir! Angus said I’d stolen it. All he did was–”

​

“I don’t want to hear it from either of you right now!” The principal bellowed, which caused my head to jump up and look at him. His face was red with rage, hair jutting out at wild angles all over his head, eyes cloaked in shadows and tie hanging loose in his white suit. The motivational posters hung around his office advising the benefits of keeping calm and hanging in there seemed like a cruel joke now as I looked at the man he’d become

 

“Now Angus, tell me exactly what you saw on the night of the disco,” the principle said, trying and failing to keep his voice level.

 

“I saw Yaz leave the hall and walk towards the principal’s office–”

 

“I was going that way because my parents were parked outside and it’s the only way out of the school.”

 

“Yaz, be quiet, I’m talking to Angus. Angus did you see her go into my office.”

 

“Well… no, it was too dark, but I know she’s the one who took it.”

 

“Alright that’s enough Angus, you can head back to lunch now,” the principal said.

 

“But–”

​

“Back to lunch! Please.”

​

Angus shot filthy looks at the both of us before getting off his chair and leaving the office in a huff, slamming the door behind him. Luckily for us but unluckily for him, this whole ordeal took place in a time before surveillance cameras were placed everywhere you could possibly mount them, before our culture became so focused on surveillance that we’d all become spies on our peers. The principal let out a deep sigh before addressing the two of us.

 

“Now, I’m only going to ask you two once, did you take the diamond?”

 

We both answered no.

 

“And if we had teachers do a check of everyone’s bags, they wouldn’t find anything?”

​

We said no again.

​

“Then we have nothing else to discuss, but you’d better hope the diamond re-appears soon, or we’re all going to be in big trouble.”

​

***

​

The three of us all got off with a warning, but the diamond was never found. Over the next few weeks, memories of the diamond faded and rumours took their place that the principal had made some under-the-desk deal with the man in the dark suit to sell the school to his company so they could look for more diamonds. For much of the year the men and their machines continued to tear the soccer fields apart, but nothing like your discovery was ever found and on the last week of the year they packed up and left. Only once the men and their infernal machines had left did the sky clear and the mountain show itself once more. That same week the principal announced his retirement, looking like half of the man he was mere months ago. At the end of year assembly while he reminisced on his achievements of the school, he was met not with looks of appreciation but unbridled disgust from the teachers dotted around the hall. The man in the black suit did a very bad job of cleaning up his mess, they left the field as partially a bog and partially a toxic pit no kid could dream of ever playing in for the foreseeable future. We stayed close through the rest of the year, but that closeness came with a tension that I couldn’t put my finger on the cause of.

​

On the last day of school, you pulled me to the side and whispered you had something to show me. You led me to the end of the toxic bog, behind the groundkeeper’s shed and made sure no one was looking before removing one of your shoes. I wasn’t sure what you were trying to do until you reached into the shoe and pulled out the diamond, it still twinkling as hypnotically as ever. I didn’t ask for details on how you’d got it and just looked at you gobsmacked, your eyes dark and heavy with guilt.

​

“I understand,” I said eventually. “I know you wanted it back.”

​

You slowly shook your head but seemed to struggle to find the words.

​

“I didn’t like what it was doing to everyone,” was all you could say eventually.

​

Without saying anything more you walked up to me, grabbed my hand and placed it in my palm before closing my fingers tight. I was about to ask why before you answered for me.

 

“I’m moving away, out of town. I want you to have this in case I don’t see you again, you’ll know what to do with it.”

​

I could have asked what you meant by that but instead I just silently nodded. We stood there for a few moments, staring into each other’s souls for the last time, our hands clasped together as we breathed in and out together. Eventually though, we both became conscious of the potential for someone watching us, so I delicately slipped the diamond into my pocket and we walked back to class.

​

Those were the last words we ever spoke to each other. On the bike ride home along the river I did what I thought you would have wanted by throwing the diamond into the water, burying it under thousands of tonnes of silt and muck at the bottom of the brown murk. No one batted an eye, to the adults around it was just a kid throwing a rock into the water and watching it go splash.

​

I still think of you sometimes though, of that time, of that place, and of how different life is now. It all seemed so important, yet we never thought of the risks of getting caught. Looking back, it was one of the few times that my life felt like an adventure, before I got weighed down like we all do in the minutiae of adult life. When I think of you now I play Blue Moon. I wonder if the school ever recovered and if kids still dig in whatever’s left of the pit. Most of all, I wonder if you still think of me too.

​

​

​​​By Finn Williams

Finn Williams is a writer, English teacher and former journalist from Whanganui, Aotearoa New Zealand. Finn has loved the art and magic of storytelling since he was young boy and when he is not writing his own stories, he is imparting that love for stories onto his students in the classroom. Currently he is particularly interested in telling stories about the beauty and difficulty that comes with being human in an increasingly anti-human world. He is also in the last editing stages of writing his first novel, which he hopes to have published soon.

​

IG: @finnwriteswords

The Muffin Man

​​​​

​​​1

​​

Poughkeepsie, New York. Sugarloaf Bakery stood next to the Shell gas station, just down the road from the main interstate entrance. The bakery had a bright yellow sign and beige tiled floors. Sugarloaf Bakery mainly sold day-old pastries wrapped in cellophane. Occasionally, they’d get in fresh donuts if Fred Sugarloaf, the owner, felt like making them. Rupert Sr. worked at Sugarloaf’s Bakery for eight years. He made seven dollars and sixty-five cents an hour and it was just fine.

​

Rupert Sr. was not intelligent in the traditional sense of the word. He did not know the capital of Idaho, nor could he explain basic physics like gravity, but he knew the important things. That Mrs. Rebecca liked her coffee with two sugars, to always close the dumpster behind the shop so the rats wouldn’t get in, to leave a piece of turkey -- not ham -- in the parking lot at the end of the day for the stray cat to enjoy for supper.

​

Every Tuesday night after his shift, Rupert Sr. drove forty minutes to see his mother in Fishkill. He never arrived past six. She lived in the yellow house Rupert Sr. grew up in with a nurse and her dog. The yellow morphed into greyish over the years. His mother was sick; she had been for a while. Each time Rupert Sr. called her or visited, she told him not to worry, which of course led him to worry more.

​

It was a Tuesday in October when Rupert Sr. decided he would bring his mother a treat on his visit. She had quite the sophisticated palette: could taste the difference between butter and margarine. In her twenties, Rupert Sr.’s mother worked as a pastry chef at a prestigious French restaurant. She loved sweets tremendously.

​

Rupert Sr. had roughly twenty minutes to cook before hitting the road. He had to be expeditious.In the storage room, Rupert Sr. found a box of Betty Crocker Blueberry Muffin Mix. Simple instructions, quick bake. Perfect. Rupert Sr. grabbed his favorite beverage, a Minute Maid Lemonade, from the refrigerator case near the register and started on his muffins. Rupert Sr. always loved how the freezing cold lemonade tickled his teeth.

​

He added eggs and oil from a large plastic jug to the dry ingredients. Dried blueberries speckled the beige mixture. He picked up the bottle of lemonade for another sip, but the cap was loose. Half a cup of Minute Made lemonade splashed directly into the muffin mix, absorbing into the batter with a hiss.

​

Rupert stared at the batter. It was already 5:15. If he started over, Rupert Sr. would keep his mother waiting, and she he had asked him not to visit so late as she got tired easily. She would be frustrated with his tardiness. So, Rupert Sr. put the lemonade muffins in the oven and set the timer for fifteen minutes, despite the alternative ingredients. It was the gesture that mattered, he thought. Still, he worried his mother’s astute taste buds would catch the blunder, even in her old age.

​

As soon as the timer rang, Rupert Sr. plopped as many muffins as he could into a Tupperware and headed out, without cleaning his station. He locked up, dropped a piece of turkey on the pavement for the cat, and scurried off in his car.

​

Rupert Sr. arrived at his mother’s home at 6:13. His mother passed away at 6:05. Rupert stood on her porch and wept, the container of still-warm Minute Maid-infused Betty Crocker Blueberry Muffins in his hands.

 

 

2

​

The next morning, Rupert Sr. woke up in his childhood bedroom; the nurse had insisted he stay the night. She kindly poured him a cup of coffee with sugar. Rupert Sr.’s mother was the only family he had left. There was nothing for him to do but drive back to Poughkeepsie and get to work on time, as always.

​

Rupert Sr. moved through the bakery in a melancholy haze. But when he passed by the register, something caught his eye: a little paper flag reading “BLUEBERRY MUFFINS - $2.” There they were: two blueberry muffins, side-by-side in the display case without cellophane.

​

Rupert Sr.’s closest colleague Cheryl was working the register. He asked her where she got the two muffins sitting in the case; Cheryl said she found them that morning next to the oven. Rupert Sr.’s eyes welled with tears; his mother would never enjoy one of his terrible muffins, but at least someone else would. He sniffled back his tears and returned to work.

​

Halfway through the morning, Cheryl called Rupert Sr. to the front of the bakery. She was holding up one of the blueberry muffins.

​

“Did you make this?” Cheryl asked.

​

Rupert Sr. nodded.

​

“Well, some guy just bought it,” Cheryl said, pointing to a man pacing outside. “After eating the first one. Now he wants to know who made them. Says it’s the best muffin he’s ever tasted.”

​

Rupert Sr. was confused but went outside to meet the man anyway.

​

The man outside was named David Whitmore. He was passing through Poughkeepsie when he thought to stop for gas and a restroom. The bathroom at the gas station was occupied, so he used the one at Sugarloaf Bakery. On his way out, David spotted his favorite treat on display: blueberry muffins. Like many around blueberry muffins, he couldn’t help but buy one… and Whitmore was oh-so-glad he did, as it was the best muffin he’d ever tasted. David Whitmore

happened to be the most prestigious food critic in the continental United States. He used the words “perfect” and “transcendent” to describe Rupert Sr.’s Betty Crocker Blueberry Muffin Mix and Minute-Maid lemonade muffin. It said it had a “delicate crumb” and “ineffable notes of citrus.” He was in unmitigated awe.

​

David Whitmore asked Rupert Sr. what his secret recipe was. Rupert Sr. shrugged.

 

“Just something I threw together.”

​

One week later, David Whitmore brought Rupert Sr. to Manhattan, though he didn’t particularly want to go. He was asked to bake his muffins for a fancy restaurant’s dessert menu. The muffins sold out before the second service began. People who paid three hundred dollars for tasting menus asked if they could buy a dozen muffins to bring home. They couldn’t, because Rupert Sr. hadn’t prepared to bake that many muffins.

​

The New York Times ran a rapturous piece on Rupert Sr.’s blueberry muffins. Several food and lifestyle magazines followed suit. Within weeks, the only thing anyone talked about was Rupert Sr.’s fabled treat. Morning and late-night news shows extended invitations for appearances. The public adored him: “How could the man behind such ingenuity be so humble?”

​

In what felt like the blink of an eye and before Rupert Sr. could fully comprehend his circumstances, a man from a venture capital firm showed up at his apartment in Poughkeepsie with a contract and a pen. He offered Rupert Sr. a fantastically large sum of money for the rights to his name and his recipe. Rupert Sr. did not fully understand what he was signing. The man moved quickly, and frankly, Rupert Sr. knew little about equity or distribution or strategic brand partnerships.

​

The lawyers handled everything. Soon enough, Rupert found himself the owner of a large factory in New Jersey. His face was plastered across every grocery store in America. Rupert Sr. sold ten million boxes of his muffins in the first year. Everyone wanted to know the secret recipe. People tried to reverse-engineer the muffins for their components in labs. But they were missing

something critical.

​

Rupert Sr. never told anyone that his muffins were made of premade box mix and Minute Maid lemonade. It seemed too stupid to say out loud, plus, he’d signed an NDA. He often pondered why no one connected the dots between the increased demand for Betty Crocker Blueberry Muffin Mix and the increased supply of his own baked goods.

​

With his money, Rupert Sr. bought a small home on a big plot of land in Poughkeepsie. He rescued the cat at Sugarloaf Bakery from the street and made him his own. He named him Mr. Turkey. Rupert Sr. missed his mother deeply. He swam twice a week at the YMCA where the water helped him clear his head, grieve a little less. In 2008, the company went public. Rupert Sr. became a billionaire, though the title meant little to him.

​

Rupert Sr. donated to the library and hospitals and nursing homes that had cared for his mother. He bought his mother’s home for the nurse who lived with her at the end of her life. The rest of his money sat untouched, waiting to eventually be passed on. Frankly, Rupert Sr. hadn’t the slightest clue what to do with all of it.

​

The next year, Rupert Sr. fell in love. Her name was Abby; she was a children’s swimming instructor at the YMCA. Abby wore her hair in a ponytail and giggled most of the time. They got married at the courthouse and fifteen people attended. They honeymooned in Cape Cod and Rupert Sr. didn’t think about muffins once.

​

When Abby got pregnant, Rupert Sr. cried tears of joy, wholly undone at the prospect of a family anew. Love was the only thing Rupert Sr. cared about. He wondered how anybody ever paid attention to anything else.

​

Abby and Rupert Sr. named their baby Rupert Jr.

 

 

3

​

Growing up with The Muffin Man as his father wasn’t easy for Rupert Jr. Little Rupert always knew he was different. His dad was a billionaire, a celebrity whose face he saw in every grocery store and delivery truck. But they did not live like billionaires, which was confusing. Rupert Jr. grew up in the same small house in Poughkeepsie. Rupert Sr. dropped him off at school in a Honda Accord. There was no pool at home. If Rupert Jr. wanted to swim, Rupert Sr. sent him to the Y.

​

Rupert Jr. thought all of it was bullshit.

​

The older he became, the more he wanted. Rupert Jr. felt a flagrant disconnect between the life he could have and the one his mother and father built for him. Eventually, he would take matters into his own hands; architect the “dream life” himself.

​

At eighteen, once he could access a portion of his inheritance, Rupert Jr. moved to New York City to attend NYU. He rented an expensive apartment, filled it with things, closing the gap between “stuff I own” and “stuff I could own.” Rupert Jr. loved the noise of the city and the bars and the parties and tall buildings, but most of all, he loved having an infinite pool of people who’d ask,

​

“Wait, seriously? Do you know the Muffin Man?”

​

“Yeah, my dad’s the Muffin Man,” Rupert Jr. would reply.

​

It was his most favorite interaction. It never got old. He began to live the way he always thought he should.

​

After college, Rupert Jr. worked briefly for the muffin company. They gave him a VP title and an office. He was meant to help with “marketing and expansion.” Rupert Jr. spent most of his time at work rearranging things on his desk and taking long lunches with other nepotism kids who comprised his “circle.” Rupert Jr. deserved an Olympic gold medal in floating around.

​

He nodded his head through meetings and came into the office two-to-three times a week. Naturally, no one judged Rupert Jr.’s work ethic – or lack thereof – probably because people like him weren’t expected to contribute much anyway. He rarely returned home to Poughkeepsie unless he needed money.

​

Rupert Sr. missed his son dearly. He called him once a week inviting him to dinner.Somehow, Rupert Jr. was always “too busy.”

 

When Rupert Sr. turned sixty-five, he threw a party at his house in Poughkeepsie. Rupert Jr. did not attend because it was a Friday and Fridays were his favorite nights to party. That same evening, Rupert Sr. had a heart attack. Not a big one, but a warning shot.

​

Rupert Jr. went to see his father in the hospital. He had barely noticed that Rupert Sr.’s hair had begun to grey. For the first time ever, Rupert Jr. felt irrepressible guilt. So he did not hold Rupert Sr.’s hand, secretly petrified that he would transmit his own bad feelings into his too-good father’s body. But Rupert Sr. felt no bad feelings at all… he was completely overcome with gladness in his son’s presence.

​

Rupert Sr. died two years later from congestive heart failure. He went peacefully in his sleep with Abby holding his hand and his new cat Mrs. Turkey curled up at the foot of his bed. The funeral attendance was extraordinary… people from Poughkeepsie, people from the company, and people from Sugarloaf Bakery all came together and wept for Rupert Sr; Rupert Jr. did not weep. He was stone cold. The mayor of Poughkeepsie gave a moving speech about genius and

serendipity and the universe rewarding goodness.

​

In his will, Rupert Sr. left Rupert Jr. the house in Poughkeepsie. He also left him a letter. It was short but sweet:

​

Dear Rupert Jr.,

​

I hope this letter finds you happy and healthy. And I hope you don’t have to read this soon – it would be a shame for me to die. But that’s how life goes sometimes. And my heart hasn’t been doing so well.

​

I wanted to say that I’m sorry I couldn’t give you more. A bigger life. I tried to give you what I thought mattered, but maybe I got it wrong. In the end, all that matters to me is you. So I apologize if I didn’t service you in the ways you needed, or with the things you needed.

​

The muffins were an accident. I spilled Minute Maid lemonade into Betty Crocker

Blueberry Muffin mix because I was rushing to see my mother. But I was too late and she died before I could get to her. I’ve spent every day thinking about the fifteen minutes it took me to make those muffins. I didn’t need them. I had everything I wanted, and I would have gotten to say goodbye to Grandma. I was so confused for so long. I’ve had so many questions!

​

But I think I’ve figured it out. Those muffins gave me so much. Not the money. If I hadn’t made them, I wouldn’t’ve had those questions. I wouldn’t’ve needed to swim to clear my head. I wouldn’t’ve met your mom. And I wouldn’t’ve had you. Those fifteen minutes – the worst fifteen minutes of my life – led me to the two best things in it.

​

I don’t know if there’s a God or if fate is real or if it’s all just dumb luck. But I do know that the best things in my life came from trying to make someone smile. Even when I messed it up.

​

It’s okay to mess up.

​

Love, Dad

​

It was quite difficult for Rupert Jr. to digest his father’s note. He kept it in his wallet anyway.

 

 

4

​

The two years after Rupert Jr.’s father died were bad.

​

The grief caught up with Rupert Jr. all at once, as it usually does. There was no one to sit and mourn with Rupert Jr. as his friends were not really “friends,” just fancy folks he’d go to lunch with now and then. So, to cope, Rupert Jr. partied every night and went to work hungover, when he bothered to show up at all.

​

The muffin company fired him after he missed an important distribution meeting. He understood as he hadn’t worked on anything at all. Then he was evicted from his fancy Tribeca apartment for missing his rent six months in a row, then from a studio in Queens for the very same reason. His whole world evaporated into a thin steam.

​

Eventually, Rupert Jr. had nowhere left to go but Poughkeepsie. It was September. He hadn’t been to the house let alone say the word “home” since the funeral, but that is where he found himself. Abby had been thinking of moving to an even smaller place, somewhere easier to manage. She said Rupert Sr. would want Rupert Jr. to have the house now.

​

When Rupert Jr. moved in, he couldn’t believe how little the home seemed. Mr. Turkey’s photo was still framed in the kitchen. Rupert Jr. slept in his childhood bedroom and Abby brought over soup he wouldn’t eat. Rupert Jr. thought about Rupert Sr. constantly. He wondered if goodness was built-in, like a great singing voice or an allergy?

​

In the case of the Ruperts, the universe worked simply. When Rupert Sr.’s mother passed, the world met his grief with opportunity, fortune, and love. When Rupert Jr.’s father passed, the universe met his grief with silence… because he was an expert in doing the wrong thing, and the world, patient as ever, seemed to remember.

​

Some, including Rupert Sr., call stories like his “luck.” But luck does not really exist. Something out there keeps score quietly, and that something always – no matter how long it takes – finds its way back to even. Bad things happen to good people all the time. But the energy we put into the world despite the bad things, the messes we make trying to love, are what remains in the end.

​

One Monday afternoon in May, Rupert Jr. went to the playground where his favorite ice cream truck parked on Mondays and Wednesdays at 3:30pm for the after-school rush. Rupert Sr. took Rupert Jr. to get ice cream every Monday and Wednesday as a kid. He bought his favorite treat, a Good Humor Strawberry Shortcake Bar, for the first time since he was small. Rupert Jr. was nibbling the exterior cookie crumble shell off his treat when he saw her.

 

A little girl, no older than five, sitting on a bench with her legs swinging. She had chocolate brown hair in two braids and was eating a blueberry muffin. His blueberry muffin. The wrapper with Rupert Sr.’s face smiled up at him from beside her on the bench.

​

“Is it good?” Rupert Jr. asked.

​

The little girl nodded enthusiastically, and her eyes bulged wide in delight. She swung her legs faster, crumbs tumbling down her jumper.

​

“I’m glad,” Rupert Jr. said, and for the first time in forever, he meant it.

​

He thought about his father again, questioned if love could take the shape of a muffin. Maybe goodness was something you could practice, like learning to swim. Then a woman approached with a SpongeBob SquarePants ice cream bar in her hand.

​

“Phoebe, baby, don’t talk to strangers.”

​

“It’s okay,” Rupert Jr. said quickly. “I was just saying hi.”

​

“Sorry. You can never be too careful.”

​

They started talking. Phoebe’s mother’s name was Dina and she worked at the elementary school. They came to the playground twice a week for the ice cream truck.

​

From that day on, Rupert Jr. felt different.

​

He came back on Wednesday, the next Monday, and the Wednesday after that. Dina had no idea who Rupert Jr. was and it was the freest he’d ever felt. Dina asked Rupert Jr. what movies he liked and what he was reading and if he’d seen the new exhibit at the cultural center. They dated for six months before Dina found out he was the son of The Muffin Man. Dina didn’t care at all. She knew Rupert Jr. was still Rupert Jr.

​

Dina and Rupert Jr. got married at the courthouse and ten people attended. They honeymooned in Cape Cod and Rupert Jr. didn’t think about muffins once.

​

When Dina got pregnant, Rupert Jr. cried tears of joy, wholly undone at the prospect of a family anew. Love was the only thing Rupert Sr. cared about now. He wondered how he ever paid attention to anything else.

​

They named their baby Rupert Jr. Jr., but everyone called him RJJ.

 

 

5

​

RJJ grew up in the small house in Poughkeepsie. His dad dropped him off at school in his Honda Accord. RJJ loved to swim but there was no pool at home, so Rupert Jr. took him to the Y, where Grandma Abby still volunteered on Thursdays. Rupert Jr. taught RJJ how to tie his shoes and ride a bike. He told him about his grandfather, about the accident that changed everything and about the value of making a mess. Rupert Jr. liked to say,

​

“If you’re not falling, you’re not learning.”

​

When RJJ turned thirteen, he drove down to Sugarloaf Bakery and asked for a job. Fred Sugarloaf’s daughter ran the place, and she hired RJJ on the spot even though he was far too young to be operating the bakery’s machinery.

​

Every Tuesday evening after his shift, RJJ drove fifteen minutes to see Grandma Abby. She lived alone now with a nurse who came three times a week.

​

RJJ always brought her something from the bakery. Sometimes cookies, sometimes coffee cake, sometimes donuts.

​

One day, Rupert Jr. Jr. decided he would make Grandma Abby muffins. In the storage room. He made them according to the directions packed them up in his car. When RJJ presented Grandma Abby the treat, she erupted into laughter and then tears. She took a bite; they were not transcendent. But pretty good.

​

“Did you make these?” she asked.

​

“Yeah,” RJJ said.

​

“They’re lovely,” she said, then whispered,

​

“Even better than The Muffin Man’s, but don’t worry, I won’t tell him.”

​

“Wait, Grandma, do you know The Muffin Man?!”​​

​​

​​​

​By Tess Feldman

Tess Feldman is a 24-year-old writer in Los Angeles. She has never been published before and wrote "The Muffin Man" on an airplane when she started thinking about accidental billionaires. The whole thing is very silly, and that is the point.

​

IG: @tessfeld

LinkedIn: Tess Feldman

bottom of page